Takeover Ad
Takeover Ad
14 August 2014

Will Brooks’ 50 Year Diary - watching Doctor Who one episode a day from the very start...

Day 591: Kinda, Episode Two

Dear diary,

Back when I was really enjoying The Macra Terror (and doesn’t that just feel like ages back?), I commented that it was too good to be Doctor Who. Don’t get me wrong, I love Doctor Who to pieces. Of course I do. I wouldn’t be making my way through this marathon if not! But there’s always a vague sense you get when watching that it’s simply Doctor Who. It’s rarely high art (nor does it aspire to be), and many of the people involved, especially guest actors, seem to treat it with that same sense of mind - it’s ‘only’ Doctor Who.

One of the places that Kinda is really holding up for me is that - as with parts of The Macra Terror, for me - it’s better than I’ve come to expect of the programme at this stage. Everyone involved, from the writer, to the director, the set designers, the costume-makers, and the guest cast, is treating this as something special. There’s lots of moments that I could point to here, but I think I’m going to focus specifically on our guest cast for the day, because they’re all uniformly brilliant. They’re treating it as though it were any other piece of ‘proper’ drama on television - performances that you’d be able to get away with in the most high-end production of Shakespeare, under the most exacting producers.

That’s true of everyone involved (including our regular cast - I’d hate to be excluding them here, and I’ll get on to them shortly), but it’s especiallytrue of Simon Rouse playing the part of the put-upon Hindle. The cliffhanger to yesterday’s episode requires him to go somewhat over-the-top as he declares his power of life and death over everyone else. It’s a moment that’s very easy to ham up… and I think it’s also fair to say that Rouse actually does ham it up. He goes at that scene with all he’s got and it really is a little bit over the top. What’s so wonderful about his performance in this story is that it works to take that moment too far! It all helps to add to the sense of this man completely snapping, and when he’s toned things down for today’s episode, they help to make that line even more unnerving and - yes - actually a bit scary.

I can’t stop watching him when he’s on the screen - even if he’s not the focus that that particular moment, I’m watching to see what choices he’s making with his movement, because it’s all incredibly well thought through. I think in his performance more than at any other time in the ‘classic’ series so far, you can really see the period of rehearsal before each recording session making a difference. He’s thought through every facet of this character, and he’s really giving it his all - far more than I’d usually expect to see for a few week’s work on a single Doctor Who story.

Then you’ve got Nerys Hughes as Todd - who’s almost become the defacto companion for this story! While Nyssa is asleep in the TARDIS, Tegan is off in the jungle, and Adric is pretending to go over to the dark side (again), the Doctor’s being paired up with another companion! It’s remarkable how well he works opposite a slightly older person, too, compared to the three youngsters that he’s usually with!

I suppose this is the right point to turn to my daily evaluation of Davison’s performance. He’s still feeling his way a little, but we’re more-or-less at the point where he’s settled down into a version of the character that we’ll be seeing for the next few years. There’s a lot to like in his performance today, but I can’t decide if he’s simply humouring Adric when they’re playing the ‘guess which hand’ game. To start with, I was entirely convinced that the Doctor was simply going through the motions in an attempt to pass the time in the cell, but then as the scene goes on he seems to become more and more fascinated by the idea. I don’t know if this is down to an odd bump in the performance or simply because I’m a bit dim - probably the latter!

Speaking of being a bit dim, mind, why is the Doctor so convinced that Hindle’s fear of the vegetation in the jungle is a sure sign that the man is mad? Has he already forgotten all those Terry Nation adventures he had to go through in his first few incarnations?

Add comment

  Country flag

biuquote
Loading

RSS Feed
News Key
News Home
General
The New Series
The Classic Series
Spinoffs
Merchandise
Site
Blog Entries
Reviews Key
Reviews Home
Books / Magazines
DVD / Blu-ray
Audio
Toys / Other
TV Episodes
Search