aWill Brooks’ 50 Year Diary - watching Doctor Who one episode a day from the very start...
Day 317: The Curse of Peladon, Episode Three
Dear diary,
Over the first half of this story, my biggest complaint has been that it’s simply too ‘talky’. Almost every scene boils down to the cast (some of whom are dressed in mildly amusing alien outfits) talking at each other, while not a lot else happens.There’s a scene in today’s episode, for example, where the various delegates of the Galactic Federation debate the merits of leaving the Doctor to his fate. It should be a great scene in which Jo finds herself facing a wall of opposition while trying to save her best friend’s life… but I just sort of watched it without engaging.
Equally, today’s episode has shown that when it’s done well, a dialogue-heavy scene can be absolutely brilliant. I’m thinking specifically of the exchange between Jo and King Peladon, in which she asks for his support and he tells her that he can’t give it, before asking for her hand in marriage. If you were to strip away the fact that David Troughton is wearing such a sparkly purple costume, this could very well be a scene from any period drama between a king and his love and set in a castle.
It’s helped, too, by Katy Manning turning in her best performance to date. She’s never been bad in her role, but she’s never been as good as we see here. I’ve heard people hold up her attempt at saving the Doctor’s life in The Dæmons as her golden moment (and, indeed, I believe it was scenes from that story which helped her win the job during auditions), but for me, this episode sees far and away her best acting, and it’s the first time that I think I’ve ever seen Jo as a proper grown up.
It’s a shame, then, when we see her blunder in to the tunnels and interrupt another of the Doctor’s experiments. During Episode One, I said “we’re a million miles away from the character who was introduced at the start of last season”, but suddenly we’re given a scene that’s almost identical to her very first! It feels like they’re trying to use this story to give Jo the space and freedom to grow as a character, but then every so often they need to resort to giving her that traditional ‘companion’ dialogue, so that the Doctor can explain his clever plan to the viewers at home.
It’s quite fun watching the Doctor put together this clever plan, too. Seeing him tinker with odds and ends to create the device he needs is so very right for this incarnation (there’s an image on the DVD cover art for the story that’s taken from this scene, and it’s just looks like the Third Doctor in his natural habitat!), and then it’s good to see him using this device to hypnotise Aggedor (and Jo!)
But I wonder if he’s also one of the things that’s stopping me from engaging with this story. It feels odd to not see this Doctor grounded so much in the Earth. Even during his last excursion from the planet we were in a time that looked even more like the 1970s than the actual 1970s do! For all he may look right tinkering around with technology, the Third Doctor simply looks a little out of place around these corridors and tunnels.
It is nice to see him engaging in the fight sequence at the end, and even though I knew it was a stunt man in the overhead shots, it took me a little while to actually notice it. It’s good to see him refusing to kill his opponent at the end, though I worry that it may come back to haunt him yet. In all, I’m still just not taken by this story. I’m hoping that Jo’s sudden prominence as a character may make her vital to the conclusion, and that it may be enough to give the tale a last-minute surge…
