Home Forums News & Reviews Features DWO Minecraft Advertise! About Email

The 50 Year Diary - Day 565 - State of Decay, Episode One

Will Brooks’ 50 Year Diary - watching Doctor Who one episode a day from the very start... 

Day 565: State of Decay, Episode One

Dear diary,

It’s perhaps not a particularly popular statement, but I’m really rather liking Adric! Over the years, he’s often been described as being (at least, during the creation of the character) a bit of an ‘Artful Dodger’, but I’ve never really gotten that. Now, though, actually properly watching Full Circle and today’s episode, you can see that in full swing. He obviously tries to steal the River Fruits during the last story, and later nicks some equipment for the Doctor, and here he tries to take hold of some food to keep himself going, too. I quite like this side to the character, but I don’t think it’ll stick around for very long, because I can’t remember it happening much come Season Nineteen.

I love that he’s not actually encountered the Doctor and Romana yet, either. His decision to stay aboard the TARDIS at the end of the last story was almost ‘Steven Taylor-esque’ - i.e., you didn’t actually realise he’d done it. You see him in the TARDIS, and obviously thinking about something, but it’s not until today that you realise exactly what he’s done. It’s great that he’s yet to meet his new travelling companions again, and I’m looking really forward to that happening. I also had a good laugh at his bamboozling of K9 in order to get out of the ship!

State of Decay is the only story from the E-Space trilogy which I’d ever seen in full before starting out on this marathon, and it’s usually the story that I’m thinking of when I say that I like this season. It’s also the first real example of this season doing something that I’d probably describe as being ‘lush’, with lots of rich textures and fabrics, and almost a return to the kind of Gothic styling of the Phillip Hinchcliffe era, but given a bit of a 1980s ‘new romantic’ twist. We’ll see similar trappings in the next two stories, as well, but it looks very different here, and makes the whole thing look rather more expensive than usual...

Watching it like this, though, immediately after Full Circle, you start to realise that there’s more links between the stories in this trilogy than simply being set in E-Space. Both feature a marooned space vessel, and technology that the people of this planet don’t quite understand (while the crew of the Star Liner knew how everything worked, more or less, they didn’t know what to do with it). There’s a trio of people who make the decisions and rule over everyone else, and there’s a real sense that things take took much time - whether that be the Deciders not actually, um, deciding, or the rebels here spending time to plan and plot their next move. There’s even a point where someone complains that nothing here has changed for a thousand generations, and it feels even more linked back to the previous tale.

Because I’ve seen this story before, I know what the big twist to the story is, but I’m wondering if that will be enough to make it stand out from the last one? There’s a danger that my enjoyment of Full Circle could end up rubbing off and damaging how well this one fares with me.

Add comment